HP przegrało w sądzie z dostawcą zamienników
Sprawa miała miejsce w Holandii, ale problem dotyczy także innych rynków.

Holenderski sąd najwyższy oddalił apelację HP w sprawie wytoczonej holenderskiemu e-sklepowi 123inkt.nl, który sprzedaje alternatywne tonery i tusze pod własną marką. Poprzednio sądy dwukrotnie również orzekały na korzyść przedsiębiorcy. O sprawie poinformował brytyjski CRN na stronie channelweb.co.uk.
Według informacji opublikowanej przez holenderskiego dostawcę, amerykański koncern twierdził, że ??czipy pamięci w kartridżach z etykietami 123ink naruszają jego patent. "Ten wyrok ostatecznie rozwiązuje sprawę sporu patentowego" – zapewnia firma.
HP pozwało 123inkt.nl w 2014 r., utrzymując, że czipy w kasetach tej marki miały zbyt wiele podobieństw do chronionego patentem układu pamięci HP – relacjonuje holenderska firma. Z kolei 123inkt.nl stało na stanowisku, że patent HP nie był ani nowy, ani innowacyjny, a koncern nadużył go, aby uzyskać monopol na kartridże do drukarek HP. Pierwszy wyrok na korzyść sprzedawcy zamienników zapadł w 2015 r.
HP odwołał się od tej decyzji. W 2017 r. sąd apelacyjny potwierdził, że patent HP na wspomniany czip był nieważny i powtórzył, że 123inkt nie naruszył żadnego patentu. Orzekł, że patent nie dotyczy tylko układu scalonego, ale również działania drukarki – informuje holenderska firma. HP nie zgodził się z tym wyrokiem i odwołał się do sądu najwyższego. W dniu 19 kwietnia 2019 r. podtrzymał on wcześniejszy wyrok na korzyść 123inkt.
"Oznacza to, że patent HP na czip jest nieważny i że 123inkt nie narusza żadnego patentu." – twierdzi przedsiębiorca.
Amerykański gigant wydał ponad pół miliona euro na prawników w tej sprawie. Teraz dojdą do tego koszty sądowe.
W 2016 r. 123inkt przegrał natomiast sprawę z Samsungiem o naruszenie patentów w tonerach.
Przedstawiciel HP potwierdził niedawno, że koncern będzie nadal prowadził działania przeciwko dostawcom podróbek oraz tzw. klonów (nowe wkłady innych dostawców, przeznaczone do drukarek HP), które w jego ocenie naruszają patenty. Przestrzegł partnerów przed handlem takim towarem.
Podobne aktualności
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$image_meta is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_metadata is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_image_alt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_date_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$ping_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_password is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_name is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$to_ping is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$pinged is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_content_filtered is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$guid is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$menu_order is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_mime_type is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_count is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$filter is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$image_meta is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_metadata is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_image_alt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_date_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$ping_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_password is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_name is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$to_ping is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$pinged is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_content_filtered is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$guid is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$menu_order is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_mime_type is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_count is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$filter is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$image_meta is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_metadata is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_image_alt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_date_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$ping_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_password is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_name is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$to_ping is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$pinged is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_content_filtered is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$guid is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$menu_order is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_mime_type is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_count is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$filter is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$image_meta is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_metadata is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_image_alt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_date_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$ping_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_password is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_name is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$to_ping is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$pinged is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_content_filtered is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$guid is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$menu_order is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_mime_type is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_count is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$filter is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$image_meta is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_metadata is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_image_alt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_date_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$ping_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_password is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_name is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$to_ping is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$pinged is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_content_filtered is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$guid is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$menu_order is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_mime_type is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_count is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$filter is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$image_meta is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_metadata is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$_wp_attachment_image_alt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_date_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$ping_status is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_password is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_name is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$to_ping is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$pinged is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_modified_gmt is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_content_filtered is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$guid is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$menu_order is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$post_mime_type is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$comment_count is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
Deprecated: Creation of dynamic property Timber\Image::$filter is deprecated in /home/sarotaq/crn/wp-content/plugins/timber-library/lib/Core.php on line 71
HP: „W IV kw. utrzymają się trudne warunki”
Słabnący popyt konsumencki ograniczył sprzedaż HP w III kw. Mimo to wzrósł zysk.